By Thom Little, Ph.D.
Well, another election has come and gone, and the post-election analysis has begun. What message(s) were the voters trying to send? Why were so many(1) Americans motivated to turn out in a midterm election? There is no shortage of answers to these questions from politicians, pundits, and prognosticators. Some have suggested that voters were motivated by frustration regarding issues like the economy, inflation, data centers, and the war in Iran. Others argue that it was, as is usually the case with midterm elections, disappointment with the party in power at the national level and the presidency in particular. A third response is that the results reflected an electorate with an unusually high turnout among women, voters of color, and younger voters that was significantly different from 2024.
While I suspect there is some validity in each of these arguments, there is one other explanation that is beginning to get some traction that I would like to explore more thoroughly: voters are frustrated with the state of American politics today, arguing that politics has become too vindictive and mean-spirited, with more emphasis on personal attacks, “gotcha” politics, childish name-calling, and blind partisanship than on attempts to pass good legislation and address the problems that concern most Americans.
Many campaigns were characterized by the usual distortions, misinformation, half-truths, and character assassinations, often aided for the first time by AI-generated advertisements that made it even more difficult for voters to discern fact from fiction. However, there seemed to be more pushback than in the recent past from voters and even some partisan politicos to ads and statements that may have been beyond the pale. For example, many were turned off by derogatory nicknames for candidates James Talarico and Dr. Annie Andrews and ads like the one run by an Ohio gubernatorial candidate featuring the estranged mother of his opponent. Following concerns raised by leaders of both parties, the candidate took the ad off the air.
On the flip side, several candidates seemed to be featuring more positive messages emphasizing a desire to build relationships across partisan divides and harking back to a nostalgic (and maybe partly fictional) time when people felt more connected to their neighbors. In North Carolina, former governor and attorney general Roy Cooper, in addition to noting concerns about inflation, built a campaign around a government that worked across party lines to improve lives. In Texas, seminarian James Talarico spoke often of the biblical obligation to “love thy neighbor,” regardless of who they are. A bit north of Texas, in Kansas, Rev. Adam Hamilton spoke of being a Matthew 25 Christian, dedicated to a government and society that takes care of “the least of these.” Clearly, given the margin of victory of each of these candidates, these messages resonated.
Now, don’t get me wrong. Even with their positive messages, these candidates still played hardball and went hard after their opponents on issues and perceived character flaws. Talarico did not let Texans forget some of the personal and political scandals that burdened his opponent, and Cooper, a 40-year veteran of electoral politics, was referred to by some as “Mr. Rogers with a switchblade!” Hamilton called out his opponent for legal actions taken while he was in the private sector.
Perhaps even more heartening than positive messaging is the number of winning candidates, particularly newly elected governors in Texas, Ohio, Georgia and Florida, that I have heard committing to “be the governor of all the people” in their states, even those who voted for their opponent. I understand that actions matter more than words, but I also think words matter, and these governors-elect have set the expectation that they will govern for all. The fact that many of these newly elected governors won in states where the opposing party wields significant power will necessitate them turning their words into action, reaching across the partisan divide to build governing coalitions. In Texas, the incoming Speaker of the House and Lt. Governor have each created bipartisan groups to assist with their transitions.
Even losing candidates seem to be getting in on the effort. After wishing his opponent “the very best as he prepares to serve as Wisconsin’s next governor,” Republican Tom Tiffany added that “democracy depends on our ability to disagree and still work together.” In his concession speech, defeated Congressman Mike Lawler (R-NY) noted, “We don’t have to agree on everything. And by the way, we shouldn’t. That’s the whole point of a constitutional republic. That’s the whole point of a democracy.”
Exit polls suggest that a significant number of voters do desire a less confrontational and less partisan political environment. Americans long for what David Axelrod, former Democratic advisor, described as “ a season of decency,” and Lydia Polgreen wrote of the election, “decency won.” Robert Reich, former US Secretary of Labor chimed in, “Americans soundly rejected the politics of hate and fear and embraced common decency.”
I may be wrong, but it feels like the winds of change are blowing, and they seem to be blowing in the direction of politics marked a little less by vitriol and anger and a little more by respect, decency, and civility. Only time will tell, but we can hope and maybe even do our part to make it so.
(1) Turnout in 2026 was third only to 1914 and 2018 for midterm elections.
